[The reason why I’m writing about nuclear power plants]
- First of all, to clarify my identity, I am not an anti-nuclear personnel. However, I sometimes think that I want to write a rebuttal when there are claims that are not true of some pro-nuclear personnel. I am not a person who has nothing to do with nuclear power at all. My master’s thesis was on nuclear fusion. When I was in my master’s degree, I spent more time at a nuclear research institute in Gongneung than at a school. The design and operation of a Mark Generator for a magnetic definition device for plasma shielding was the subject of my thesis.
There are angry comments from some people working in nuclear power plants about the post in front of this article, so I post about why I posted it and how I want the conversation to proceed. - Recently, Dr. J, who is well-known in the nuclear world, posted a chart of power generation costs for each country. Prior to this, another nuclear figure who posted the same chart posted an article with the intention that the public should be grateful for renewable energy and cheap nuclear power plants. When I saw this article, I thought as follows.
“I raised my child (nuclear power plant) with all the money I had and didn’t have, and I didn’t get married over the age of 50 and lived in my parents’ house (while still receiving state subsidies), and I gave my parents pocket money that they said they should be thankful for their children.”
Dr. J posted the same chart and made a comment to the effect that power sources with different roles within one system are not comparable and that other power sources are not expensive under the same conditions. I decided to write a series of the previous article (the story of a nuclear power plant that no one else does) after thinking of writing about a part that is not well known about nuclear power plants. - Dr. B, Dr. Y, and Dr. P in the nuclear world commented angrily when the first article of “Nobody’s Story of Nuclear Power Plant” was released.
Dr. B, who is known to be the owner of a smooth personality in his usual writings and rumors, and Dr. Y, who has a good personality who once thought he got along well, saw the angry comments again, and I felt sorry, but I do not intend to revise my article’s purpose that the climate change mitigation effect is minimal due to the low proportion of nuclear power plants, nuclear power plants are increasingly emitting carbon, and the COP 28 Nuclear Declaration can make it worse. - And if there is no answer to the rebuttal comment during the comment conversation about the objection, it seems to be thinking like a subpoena, such as “You admitted to being wrong” or “You ran away because you were confused about the answer.”
There are three reasons why I don’t comment on comments.
1) If the facts are different
2) If there’s no point in talking anymore
3) an impolite case
For example, there were cases as follows. When I asked if there was any basis for the claim that the LCOE of the Barakah nuclear power plant was low when talking about the LCOE of the nuclear power plant, and they answered, “I heard that the LCOE of the Barakah APR 1400 4th term is low at KRW 24 trillion.” I did not comment anymore because the first reason is that the claim that “the construction cost is KRW 24 trillion” has a different factual relationship and “I heard it” so I did not comment. The Barakah APR 1400 4th term is KRW 40 trillion including Owner Cost
It cost me more than ($31.2 billion) and I didn’t comment on it because “I heard” is not an official record, so I don’t think any more conversations are going to work.
Another example is, “You’re ignorant,” “You’re as good as an elementary school student,” etc., and when I claim that there is data, “Give it to me.” I don’t respond to comments that don’t respect the other person at all. If you don’t answer like this, the comments that come back are like, “You admit you’re wrong,” or even, “You ran away because you couldn’t answer.” - Unless I’m a god, what I post on the Internet can’t be perfect. If I point out that there’s something wrong, I’m willing to correct it. I’ve revised it to reflect some of the actual points. And if you seem truly ignorant, and you think about it at the elementary school level, shouldn’t you explain it in an easy-to-understand way with your compassion?
My writing isn’t one that has the power to move a lot of people. It’s about 100 people at the most who press “like” at the most. It’s not one that has enough influence to worry the angry people, so just think to yourself, “Some crazy guy wrote this.”
If you want to comment, I would like to exchange common sense conversations. I think you will interpret it wisely through the conversation that you give and take.